BHOPAL XXV *

D-21 | Photo du jour

Rashida Bee

In 2004, Rashida Bee and Champa Devi received the "Goldman Prize for Excellence in Protecting the Environment", in recognition of their exemplary 20 years struggle. They used the $125,000 in prize money in aid of their NGO, the Chingari Trust, that provides medical aid to children born with congenital malformations. They created, in their turn, the "Chingari Award for Women Against Corporate Crime" recognizing women fighting corporate crime across India. The first ceremony, held in Bhopal in 2007, was a great success.

Image: © Micha Patault

As for orange agent used during the war of Vietnam (produced amongst other things by Dow and Monsanto), the residues and pesticides produced by Union Carbide cause congenital malformations (respiratory/circulatory system, muscle-skeleton…). Exposure of children is double: in utero + breast-feeding, and by drink water (a child drinks 2,5 times more water, relatively to its weight, compared to an adult). The women exposed to the pesticides by their environment, have 2 times more risks to make abortion in consequence of malformation of the foetus.

"Here, adults were victims of gas, and now, children are victims of water" said Poona Bai, mother of Raj, who cannot walk and has an oversize head.

D-22 | Picture of the day

Shanti, 70 years old

Shanti worked in an hospital the night of December 3, 1984. "When I arrived at the house, my 2 sons were unconscious. Dilip, the youngest, died later of tuberculosis at 22 years, undoubtedly contracted because of exposure to the gaz".

Image: © Stéphane Bouillet

Tuberculosis seems to reach the 2 generations of victims:

  • the insufficient respiratory ones, weakened because their lungs were touched by gas in 1984
  • inhabitants in the neighbourhoods of the factory, drinking daily contaminated water. Pesticides express carcinogenic, mutagen, but also immunotoxic properties: they disturb the operation of the immune system, which weaken the people face to diseases like tuberculosis. The pesticides act even with very low dose, especially if daily exposure is repeated since years and years.

Tuberculosis strikes here three times more than in the remainder of India.

D-23 | Picture of the day

Saddam 15 years old

Saddam suffers fom anemia.

Image: © Kostas Pliakos

Anaemias are due to the contamination of water by pesticides left in the plant and washed by rainwater (there are still pesticides on the spot). Indeed, Union Carbide left without cleaning up the site. Moreover, according to former workers of the Union Carbide factory, while the factory was in operation, massive amounts of chemicals - including pesticides, solvents, catalysts and wastes - were routinely dumped in and around the factory grounds. These include deadly substances such as aldicarb, carbaryl, mercury, and several chlorinated chemicals.

  • 52% of women suffurs from anemia in India [1]
  • 95% of women suffurs from anemia in Atal Ayub Nagar (a community affected by water contamination) [2]

D-24 | Picture of the day

Hajra Bee, 52 years old

A devout Muslim, she refused to continue wearing a burka after the disaster. "I had to go out and work myself to sustain the needs of my family. The burka no longer had any importance…" Shortly after the disaster, her husband abandoned the family, leaving her alone with their four children.
She is a gas survivor and lives in J.P. Nagar, a neighbourhood right next to the factory. "In the night of December 3, a friend, pregnant and mother of a 15 months old girl, has been electrocuted in an electric station: she couldn't see anything"
Hajra has led the life of an activist. "I am determined to march until I meet the Prime Minister and ask him to respect our rights."

Image: © Micha Patault

D-25 | Picture of the day

Shakira, 18 years old

Shakira is smaller than the other children of her age. Following malformations on the feet, she cannot walk, even with helps. The doctors could not help her.

Image: © Stéphane Bouillet

Union Carbide has never shown any interest in the condition of its victims, said Sunil Kumar, who lost his entire family during the original gas leak. We've always known that. Now it seems they know that their factory is poisoning a whole new generation - and they are doing nothing to stop it. People are ill in the communities. Babies are sick. There are many deformed births. It's as if they really hate us. As if they are trying to punish us for protesting when they gassed us before and killed our families. What kind of people are they to do this?

D-26 | Picture of the day

Nasrana, 13 years old

Nasrana has thyroid problems, and was operated of the thyroid. With a family of 6 children, her parents have difficulties to pay the doctors and drugs necessary to its medical monitoring.

Image: © Kostas Pliakos

Some victims touched by gas on 1984 had obtained a thin compensation (500$), but victims of the 2nd generation don't have any financial aid from Union Carbide or Dow. An hospital dedicated to the victims (Bhopal Memorial Hospital and Research Centers, BMHRC) was inaugurated in 1998 only.

Victims, when they can, go especially in 2 specialized centres:

  • the Sambhavna Trust Clinic (ayurveda, panchakarma...)
  • and the Chingary Trust, particularly dedicated to children of the 2nd generation who continue to be born with deficiencies (physical, mental…). Sometimes this center sets up repairing surgeries with other organizations.

D-27 | Picture of the day

Chote Khan, 70 years old

In 1984, he and his wife, Munni Bee, lived in Rajgarh Colony, 500 metres from the Union Carbide factory. The gas caused him chronic asthma attacks and his eyes burned continuously. Since then, he has been unable to do manual labor and has had to limit his working hours. They had to sell their house for a more modest dwelling in Blue Moon Colony, a neighbourhood right next to the factory. “Nobody knew that the water was contaminated here. It’s true that the water tasted horrible and had a strange odor, but we hadn’t imagined that it contained toxic chemicals." Daily consumption of this water damaged the health of the entire family, including grandson and granddaughter. The mother of Chote, who was exposed to the gas, died following a long period of illness.

Image: © Micha Patault